Sam asks the question that’s on all of our minds: is that the Mark of Cain or Dean talking? “Doesn’t matter,” Dean says, cold, turning on his heel to go, and we are left stunned by how cruel he is being to the brother he raised and protected. And he’s going to rip apart everyone and everything they ever loved, and then he’s going to tear out their heart. Sam: “You think I’m… you think I’m ever going to forgive myself for that?”ĭean: “You know what I think? I think it should be you up there, not her.”ĭean demands Sam shut the whole thing down. Nice shot.”Īnd Sam looks as hurt and guilty as if he killed Charlie himself, but the thing is? Dean’s not wrong, which justifies, in his mind anyway, the final blow. And listen, I had a shot…”ĭean: “Yeah, you had a shot. So of course I was gonna fight for you because that’s what we do. But when it’s done with you, you won’t be you anymore. Sam: “What was I supposed to do, just watch you die?” Sam wants to explain but Dean doesn’t care to hear it. They watch her burn, and Sam begins to eulogize (and apologize) before Dean cuts him off, reminding Sam that he got her killed and he doesn’t get to say he’s sorry for that. Dean leans over her for the tiniest of moments, pained but not breaking. Dean carries Charlie’s small body over and Sam helps him lift it up onto the wood. I know.” “I forgive you, Dean.” A lovely song plays in the background, and as I hear “You don’t ever have to go to war no more…” my tears for her fall. While the boys chop and collect wood for Charlie’s funeral pyre, they remember her via flashback, and it is so damned painful. Just as I did with Kevin Tran, I sincerely hoped this week would open with the discovery that Charlie was not dead, and, just like last time, I was crushed with disappointment.

He’s sensitive and thoughtful, and he does not want anything to do with his family. This introduction and the moments to come defined Cyrus quite nicely. The bully knocks him down, prompting Cousin Eli to come to the rescue, and allowing him to analyze the bully far less critically but accurately (he calls him a dickbag.) Later, the bully gets bagged by Eli (no, literally) and we know this is going to end up, at best, with him being an amputee. He’s looking at you, right?) Cyrus refuses to engage and then shuts him down with a scathing analysis that even makes the bully’s cronies laugh. What? Cyrus Styne, the baby of the family, is bullied at school by a kid with a douchey ‘do who wants to know if he has ever seen a boob in the wild. And third? Their family may have a long history of dissecting people for parts. Second? You may end up working for that kid someday. There’s a lot of reasons not to pick on the school nerd. As we go into this week’s episode the question is: how much of Dean is Dean anymore? And how much of him is owned by the Mark? I’m sure Charlie, the beloved little sister he never knew he needed, would have wanted Dean to remember her, but not like this. It seems the death of Charlie was the catalyst Dean needed to evolve into what he dreaded becoming, a cold-blooded killer like Cain who slaughters the innocent merely based on their bloodline. Hell hath no fury like a Winchester scorned.

Hey man nice shot supernatural